ShipworkSite inspection
Checks

Crawlability

PaginationAre paginated pages set up right?Internal searchIs site search eating crawl budget?URL parametersAre parameters creating duplicates?Log analyserWhat does Googlebot actually crawl?Robots builderNeed a robots.txt file?Soft 404sAre pages “not found” but returning 200?JavaScriptCan crawlers see it without running JS?FreshnessIs my site quietly going stale?Robots.txtDoes robots.txt say what I think?

Indexing

Sitemap lastmodAre my sitemap dates valid?SitemapIs my sitemap actually fetchable?IndexingIs Google allowed to index my pages?CanonicalsIs Google indexing the wrong URL?Index signalsDo sitemap and index signals agree?Sitemap generatorNeed a sitemap.xml for my site?Bulk URL statusWhere does each of these URLs really land?Redirect builderNeed the redirect rules?RedirectsAre my URLs answering directly, over HTTPS?

On-page

Keyword ideasWhat are people searching for?SERP previewHow does my page look in Google?Content qualityAre your pages too thin or too alike?Image weightAre images slowing the page?CannibalizationAre pages competing with each other?On-page checkDoes the page use its target phrase?ImagesAre my images accessible and loading?Meta tag builderWhat should my title and share tags say?DuplicatesDo my pages compete for one query?

Links

Orphan pagesWhich pages can no link reach?Link graphHow deep do your pages sit?Anchor textDo links say what they point at?Outbound linksAre external links still alive?Broken linksAre internal links sending visitors nowhere?

Structured data

Rich resultsIs my markup eligible for a rich result?Structured dataIs my product schema valid?Schema coverageDo my key pages carry structured data?Social previewHow does my page look when shared?Schema vs pageDoes markup match the page price?Schema builderNeed valid JSON-LD?

International

Hreflang sitemapDo page and sitemap hreflang agree?HreflangDo my language versions link back?Hreflang builderNeed the hreflang tags?Page DoctorWhy is this page not doing well?Redirect planMy site has dead links — what redirects do I write?Sitemap diffIs anything missing from my sitemap?Robots simulatorWhat does my robots.txt actually block?Can Googlebot?Can Googlebot fetch this URL?
Every error, explainedGuides
Pricing Learn Error guides Run free audit

+1 free check

Welcome to Shipwork

Sign in free and your next check this month is on us.

Continue with GoogleContinue with email

We email you a 6-digit code. No password.

No card needed. Reports and watches follow you to any device.

404 vs 410: which should a removed page return?

Both tell Google the page is not there. 404 says “not found”, 410 says “gone, on purpose”. Google drops both from the index; a 410 can be processed slightly faster. The bigger decision is whether the page should redirect instead.

One crawl of a set of public pages, from outside your network. Nothing is stored.

The difference

404 Not Found410 Gone
MeaningNothing at this URL, cause unspecifiedRemoved deliberately and not coming back
Google indexingDropped after recrawlsDropped, sometimes a little sooner
RecrawlingGoogle may keep checking for a whileGoogle may keep checking for a while
Typical useMistyped or never-existing URLsDiscontinued products, deleted content

Google has said that in the long run it treats 404 and 410 almost the same. Neither causes a site-wide penalty; having 404s is normal.

When to redirect instead

If the removed page has a close replacement, such as a newer product or an updated article, use a 301 redirect to it. That keeps visitors and links. Do not redirect every removed page to the homepage: Google may treat that as a soft 404.

When to use 410

  • A product is discontinued with no replacement and you want it out of search quickly.
  • Spam or hacked pages were removed and should be dropped fast.
  • A whole section was deliberately retired.

Check what your URLs return

Paste the removed URLs into the bulk status checker to confirm each returns the code you intended, and that none returns 200 with a “not found” message, which Google reports as a soft 404.

Related explainers

Questions

Is 410 better than 404 for SEO?
Slightly faster removal at most. Both remove the page from the index; neither hurts the rest of the site.
Should I redirect deleted pages?
Only to a genuinely relevant replacement. Otherwise return 404 or 410.
Do 404 errors hurt rankings?
No. Google expects some 404s. Fix them only when the URL should exist or has valuable links.