The difference
| 404 Not Found | 410 Gone | |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Nothing at this URL, cause unspecified | Removed deliberately and not coming back |
| Google indexing | Dropped after recrawls | Dropped, sometimes a little sooner |
| Recrawling | Google may keep checking for a while | Google may keep checking for a while |
| Typical use | Mistyped or never-existing URLs | Discontinued products, deleted content |
Google has said that in the long run it treats 404 and 410 almost the same. Neither causes a site-wide penalty; having 404s is normal.
When to redirect instead
If the removed page has a close replacement, such as a newer product or an updated article, use a 301 redirect to it. That keeps visitors and links. Do not redirect every removed page to the homepage: Google may treat that as a soft 404.
When to use 410
- A product is discontinued with no replacement and you want it out of search quickly.
- Spam or hacked pages were removed and should be dropped fast.
- A whole section was deliberately retired.
Check what your URLs return
Paste the removed URLs into the bulk status checker to confirm each returns the code you intended, and that none returns 200 with a “not found” message, which Google reports as a soft 404.
- Bulk URL status checkerCheck up to 100 URLs free.
- Soft 404 fixWhen a missing page returns 200.
- 404 in Search ConsoleWhich 404s matter and which to ignore.
- Redirect generator301 rules for nginx, Apache, Netlify and Cloudflare.
Related explainers
- Why is my page not indexed
- robots.txt vs noindex
- Missing canonical
- Free technical SEO audit
- AI crawler user agents
- GPTBot user agent
- OAI-SearchBot user agent
- ChatGPT-User user agent
- ClaudeBot user agent
- Claude-SearchBot user agent
- PerplexityBot user agent
- Google-Extended user agent
- Applebot-Extended user agent
- CCBot user agent
- Bytespider user agent
- Meta-ExternalAgent user agent
- Amazonbot user agent
- SEO MCP server
- hreflang vs canonical
- What is a canonical tag